Best Mysterious Movies & TV Series of the 2000s

3eyedraven's 13 top-rated mysterious movies and TV series of the 2000s — ordered by how strongly audiences rate them and how many actually voted, so the ranking reflects real consensus. Full details on each.

Monster 2004 ★ 8.5
Yu-Gi-Oh! Duel Monsters 2000 ★ 8.3
Mystic River 2003 ★ 7.7
Paranoia Agent 2004 ★ 7.9
Scooby-Doo! Pirates Ahoy! 2006 ★ 7.5
The Illusionist 2006 ★ 7.3
New Tricks 2004 ★ 7.3
New Amsterdam 2008 ★ 7.1
The Dresden Files 2007 ★ 7.0
What Lies Beneath 2000 ★ 6.4
The Ring Two 2005 ★ 5.8
Dreamcatcher 2003 ★ 5.6
Eternal 2004 ★ 4.2