Best Incredulous Movies

Looking for the best incredulous movies? These 26 are the highest-rated on 3eyedraven, weighted by vote count so a handful of glowing reviews never beats a proven favourite.

Castle in the Sky 1986 ★ 8.0

Evangelion: 2.0 You Can (Not) Advance 2009 ★ 7.8

Brazil 1985 ★ 7.7

Arrival 2016 ★ 7.6

The Unforgivable 2021 ★ 7.4

An American Werewolf in London 1981 ★ 7.4

This Is It 2009 ★ 7.4

Dead Man Walking 1995 ★ 7.3

13 Hours: The Secret Soldiers of Benghazi 2016 ★ 7.3

Set It Off 1996 ★ 7.2

Brian Banks 2019 ★ 7.2

The Accountant² 2025 ★ 7.1

In the Loop 2009 ★ 7.0

Alive 1993 ★ 6.9

Fatal Attraction 1987 ★ 6.8

Romeo + Juliet 1996 ★ 6.8

Primer 2004 ★ 6.7

Nosferatu 2024 ★ 6.7

Alice in Wonderland 2010 ★ 6.6

Melinda and Melinda 2004 ★ 6.2

Chappaquiddick 2018 ★ 6.1

The Blue Lagoon 1980 ★ 6.1

I Am Greta 2020 ★ 5.9

Perfect Stranger 2007 ★ 5.8