Supernatural Horror's Greatest Years, Ranked

When was the golden age of Supernatural Horror? We ranked every year by the accumulated weighted rating of its best Supernatural Horror titles — a year rises when it delivered many strongly-rated entries, not just a lone classic. Data from 3eyedraven's catalog.

1. #1 2025 25 great titles Best: IT: Welcome to Derry
2. #2 2024 20 great titles Best: Jentry Chau vs the Underworld
3. #3 2026 16 great titles Best: Obsession
4. #4 2023 14 great titles Best: Five Nights at Freddy's
5. #5 2020 11 great titles Best: Tale of the Nine Tailed
6. #6 2022 10 great titles Best: FROM
7. #7 2019 10 great titles Best: Marianne
8. #8 2011 8 great titles Best: American Horror Story
9. #9 2015 5 great titles Best: Insidious: Chapter 3